b2KIT

Retirement Withdrawal Strategy Planner

Model withdrawal sequences across taxable, tax-deferred, and Roth accounts to minimize lifetime tax burden with Roth conversion ladder.

Tested tool guide Tested browser tools Checked August 16, 2026

What Retirement Withdrawal Strategy Planner does, with a checked example

This planner models year-by-year withdrawal sequences across taxable, tax-deferred, and Roth accounts from your balances, annual spending, and tax-bracket assumptions. It chooses the order that minimizes lifetime tax, not this year's tax, and it sizes a Roth conversion ladder: annual conversions that fill low-bracket headroom, each starting its own five-year clock. The surprise most people hit: a conversion is taxable income in the year you convert it. Converting from a high bracket raises tax today; the ladder only pays off when it fills brackets you would otherwise leave empty.

Worked example

A concrete input and expected output from the current implementation.

Input

Annual spending: $70,000. Traditional IRA: $600,000. Roth IRA: $150,000. Taxable brokerage: $0. Tax brackets: 10% on the first $20,000 of withdrawals, 12% on the next $30,000, 22% above $50,000. Tax paid out of the withdrawal.

Expected output

Year 1: take $20,000 from the traditional IRA at 10% ($2,000 tax), $30,000 at 12% ($3,600), and the remaining $20,000 at 22% ($4,400). Total withdrawn: $70,000; total tax: $10,000. The Roth IRA stays untouched at $150,000; the traditional IRA is left with $530,000.

The planner spends Roth dollars last, so the full $70,000 comes from the traditional IRA and is taxed in the three entered brackets: $20,000 at 10%, $30,000 at 12%, and $20,000 at 22%. Those pieces come to $2,000 + $3,600 + $4,400 = $10,000 in tax, and $600,000 - $70,000 leaves $530,000.

How the result is produced

1

Withdrawal ordering by tax cost

Each year the planner sorts your cash need across account types. Taxable brokerage dollars are spent first, because only capital gains are taxed. Tax-deferred accounts are then withdrawn up to your chosen bracket ceiling, and Roth dollars are drawn last: their growth is permanently tax-free and they have no required minimum distributions. The sequence is recomputed every year as balances, brackets, and spending change.

2

The Roth conversion ladder

The conversion component moves a chosen amount from the traditional IRA to the Roth each year. The converted amount is taxable income that year, so the planner caps conversions at the headroom below your next bracket ceiling. Each conversion runs its own five-year clock: principal withdrawn inside five tax years takes the 10% early-distribution penalty; after that it is penalty-free, and conversions also shrink future required minimum distributions.

Good uses

  • A 52-year-old who retires early and needs income for the years before 59 1/2, converting a slice of the traditional IRA each year so the money becomes penalty-free after each five-year clock.
  • A retiree in the gap between a last paycheck and Social Security, with a few empty low-bracket years, deciding how much to convert each year before a pension or benefit fills those brackets.
  • Someone with a heavy traditional-IRA balance weighing whether to spend taxable assets first or convert aggressively now to shrink later RMDs and IRMAA surcharges.

Limits and checks

  • The plan is only as good as the tax assumptions you enter. Brackets, standard deductions, IRMAA thresholds, and state tax change most years, so a sequence optimized against this year's numbers can be wrong a decade later. Re-run the planner annually and after any tax-law change.
  • Conversions are ordinary income, and income drives Social Security benefit taxation, Medicare IRMAA surcharges, and ACA premium credits. If the planner does not model those, a conversion that looks cheap can carry hidden costs the tool never shows.
  • The five-year clock is per conversion, and Roth distributions come from contributions first, then oldest conversions, then earnings. Spending converted money before its own five years are up triggers the 10% penalty, so check the early years of any plan by hand.

Common questions

Why does the planner spend my Roth last when tax-free money now is obviously better?

Because Roth growth is permanently tax-free and Roth balances have no required minimum distributions, spending those dollars first forfeits the most valuable money you own. Taxable and traditional withdrawals cost less today or defer tax entirely. The exception is a year with a large income spike or subsidy-sensitive income, where the planner may deliberately switch the order.

I am 55 and everything sits in a 401(k). Can I use the ladder?

The ladder runs through Roth IRAs. You can roll a 401(k) into a traditional IRA, usually without tax, then convert from there, or convert directly if the plan permits in-service conversions. The converted amount is still taxable that year. Also consider the rule of 55: money left in your current employer's plan is penalty-free if you separate from service in or after the year you turn 55.

References and verification

The example and behavioral notes were checked against the browser implementation. Standards and primary references below define the relevant format, formula, or platform behavior.

Related Tools